1971 – St. Andrews

GB&I 13 – 11 USA

May 26-27, 1971
The Old Course, St. Andrews, Fife, Scotland
6,951 yards / Par 72

Captain: Michael Bonallack (GB&I) and John Winters (USA)

Day 1 Foursomes (GB&I players first)
Michael Bonallack / Warren Humphreys beat Lanny Wadkins / Jim Simons 1 hole
Charles Green / Roddy Carr beat Steve Melnyk / Marvin Giles III 1 hole
David Marsh / George Macgregor beat Allen Miller III / John Farquhar 2&1
Scott Macdonald / Rodney Foster beat Bill Campbell / Tom Kite Jr 2&1
GB&I 4 – USA 0

Day 1 Singles
Charles Green lost to Lanny Wadkins 1 hole
Michael Bonallack lost to Marvin Giles III 1 hole
Geoff Marks lost to Allen Miller III 1 hole
Scott Macdonald lost to Steve Melnyk 3&2
Roddy Carr halved with Bill Hyndman III
Humphreys lost to Jim Gabrielson 1 hole
Hugh Stuart beat John Farquhar 3&2
Rodney Foster lost to Tom Kite Jr 3&2
GB&I 1.5 – USA 6 .5

Day 1: GB&I 5.5 – USA 6.5

Day 2 Foursomes
Geoff Marks / Charles Green lost to Steve Melnyk / Marvin Giles III 1 hole
Hugh Stuart / Roddy Carr beat Lanny Wadkins / Jim Gabrielson 1 hole
David Marsh / Michael Bonallack lost to Allen Miller III / John Farquhar 5&4
Scott Macdonald / Rodney Foster halved with Bill Campbell / Tom Kite Jr
GB&I 1.5 – USA 2.5

Day 2 Singles
Michael Bonallack lost to Lanny Wadkins 3&1
Hugh Stuart beat Marvin Giles 2&1
Warren Humphreys beat Steve Melnyk 2&1
Charles Green beat Allen Miller III 1 hole
Roddy Carr beat Jim Simons 2 holes
George Macgregor beat Jim Gabrielson 1 hole
David Marsh beat Bill Hyndman III 1 hole
Geoff Marks lost to Tom Kite Jr 3&2
GB&I 6 – USA 2

Match Result: GB&I 13 – USA 11

Series Results: USA 20 – GB&I 2 – Halved 1 (after Match 23)


GB&I Team – Back D. Marsh, C. Green, H. Stuart, M. Bonallack, R. Foster, G. Macgregor; Front W. Humphries, G. Marks, S. Macdonald, R. Carr.
(Photo: Peter Grunwell)

Match Notes

From 1971 halved games started to be counted towards the match score, with 0.5 points awarded to each side.

John Winters, a past president of the USGA in 1962 and 1963, became just the second non-Walker Cup playing captain for the USA team.

Lanny Wadkins and Tom Kite both played for the USA before turning pro and enjoying notable PGA Tour careers.

GB&I won the Day 1 (Wednesday) foursomes 4-0, the first time they had achieved an individual series whitewash. Unfortunately their advantage was completely wiped out in the afternoon singles with USA turning the tables and winning 6.5-1.5.

Bonallack’s disappointing Walker Cup record, even in this famous GB&I victory, was encapsulated in his Singles defeat to Vinny Giles on Day 1. 1Up with three to play he bunkered his approach to the 16th to lose his lead. He then lost the 17th when Giles thinned his fourth from the shale road, hit the flag halfway up before the ball dropped straight down into the hole. Bonallack missed his four footer for a half and was unable to salvage anything on the home hole. It was reported at the time that Giles acquired the flag stick from the 17th and took it home to the USA with him.

Surprisingly Captain Bonallack’s response to his team’s historic foursomes performance on Day 1 was to change three of his four pairings for the Day 2 series. GB&I lost the second foursomes 1.5 – 2.5 falling two points behind their rivals heading into the singles.

GB&I won their second match and both were played on the Old Course at St. Andrews (1938 and 1971). David Marsh, after a memorable 3-iron to the 17th Road Hole, secured the all important winning point after George Macgregor had earlier ensured the half.

In 1971 Joe Carr, who had played in nine previous matches and captained GB&I in two more, all with out victory saw his son Roddy Carr play on a winning team, scoring an impressive 3.5 points in the process.

Scotland’s Hugh Stuart is also worthy of praise. He won all three of his games for GB&I including a critical singles win against the formidable Vinny Giles on Day 2.

This was a tight match. Of the 24 games contested only one ended before the 16th green with 13 going the full distance.

All of the 1938 GB&I side were present at St. Andrews to celebrate the 33rd anniversary of their win. Indeed two members, Cecil Ewing and Frank Pennink, were GB&I team selectors in 1971.

GB&I celebrations went on long into the night in St. Andrews. At about 3.00pm a number of the players went out onto the links to replay some of their shots. David Marsh ended up falling into the Swilcan Burn and Rodney Foster got lost returning to the private home he was staying in. Foster ended up trying another door and spending the night in a completely different house.

Only two players from the winning GB&I team would go on to turn professional.

The covers of Golf World magazine in May and July 1971 highlight just how much a shock this win for GB&I was. There is a certain irony here as Golf World’s instruction contributor at the time was John Jacobs who was also the official coach to the successful GB&I Walker Cup team.

Golf World May 1971 – Walker Cup: Britain Heading For A Hiding ?

Golf World July 1971 – Walker Cup Triumph After 33 Years Gap

Steve Melnyk beat his USA team-mate Jim Simons in the final of the Amateur Championship at Carnoustie the week after the match.

Copyright © 2015-2023, Mark Eley. All rights reserved.